The BBC Viewfinder
29 May 2009

Earlier this month the BBC News Picture Editor Phil Coomes joined the ever growing ranks of BBC bloggers with his own: Viewfinder

The blog sets out to discuss photography on the BBC News website and more widely on the subject of photojournalism and photography. Coomes himself is a photographer, studying at the BA Photography course at the University of Westminster under Tom Ang, who you may remember from the BBC TV series A digital picture of Britain

The BBC has, in my opinion, long shunned away from news photography which is understandable given it’s long history geared towards television and radio. However as one of the most trafficked news websites in the world and as more news is consumed online the BBC has lagged behind by miles with it’s use of press photography.bbcnewsgrab2Granted it has improved in recent years with it’s new larger image and headline when a big story is splashed on the front page (see above) and more recently it’s much improved galleries, which broke the ancient constraints of  the old 465 x 300 px slideshows.

There are still some problems with the new galleries, captions over photographs may be a pretty and efficient use of space if you are a web developer, but not much good if you want to look at a photograph and read the caption at the same time without ruining the aesthetics of both.

Another bugbear of mine is the lack of credits on images, usually it’s an AP, PA or Getty credit over the image, again something that irks the photography purist in me. But is it really that hard to properly credit a photographer? If they can credit every member of the production team on TV and occasionally the journalist who wrote the story online surely they can find the space for a credit for the photographer. Even the ‘Have Your Say’ comments get proper attribution.

A shining example of news photography online is the New York Times, whose stories have images over the full width of the article and often additional images for the story which can be viewed larger. Most importantly they are fully credited, even when they are from the wire agencies.

Closer to home the Guardian also plays photographs over the full width of the column and credits them properly. The Daily Mail uses images and graphics so heavily on it’s articles that if there were any more there would be nothing left but the headline. And of course there is the Boston Globe Big Picture blog, which plays images at a screen-busting 990px across.

Clearly little value is held for the still image at BBC News, apart from it’s frequent celebration of meaningless mediocrity with it’s ‘Your Pictures’ galleries which serve little other than free-content filler and a fulfilment of equally meaningless audience participation.

BBC News has an annual budget of £350 million, but from the look of it’s shockingly sparse local news sites you wouldn’t know it (a subject worthy of a blog post of it’s own). I know of one professional photojournalist who was offered a meagre £15 for a photo, he declined their offer.

Until the BBC starts paying properly for news photography it will remain full of bland audience contributed and wire agency photographs. I lay the gauntlet down to Phil Coomes and others on the BBC News Picture Desk to raise the quality of photography and to pay a decent rate for it. Here’s hoping anyway.
Journalists and their sources mini-conference
27 May 2009

sources-wide1Last night Suzanne Breen, Northern Ireland Editor of the (Dublin) Sunday Tribune, flew in to the NUJ headqaurters on Grays Inn Road to talk to members about the case being brought against her by the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) under the Terrorism Act (2000) to reveal her sources in the Real IRA.

Also speaking were Bill Goodwin, the technology journalist who set an EU legal precident to protect his source in a case brought against him by Tetra. Sir Geoffary Bindman senior lawyer and founder of Bindmans solicitors. Jo Glanville from Index on Censorship and Mark Stephens media and libel specialist lawyer with Finers Stephens Innocent.

The panel were in agreement that the the security services use of of journalists as intelligence gathers by using production orders against them was unacceptable and a threat not only to press freedom but in Breens case a threat to her life if she is forced to reveal her source.

Read the rest of this entry »

“Who’s a Journalist, Who isn’t?”
22 May 2009
Commander Broadhurst addresses the NUJ Photographers Conference

Commander Broadhurst addresses the NUJ Photographers Conference

On Monday Commander Broadhurst, head of public order at the Metropolitan Police spoke at the NUJ Photographers Conference and with all the events over the past few years he received a rather frosty response from those there.

The Commander was heckled off the platform as he began to question the legitimacy of those carrying press cards. He asked in his speech, probably rhetorically but received some very pointed answers:

I don’t know what vetting system there is for holding an NUJ card. Can anybody who has a camera apply for an NUJ card? [...] How do we manage who’s doing what? legitimately or otherwise.

- Commander Broadhurst, Metropolitan Police

He went on to question the motives of journalists working in public order situations and it quickly descended into a shouting match between the conference and the Commander. Probably sensing he had dug himself deep enough into a hole he left the platform and went into answering questions.

It’s well worth listening to both the Commanders speech and the discussion afterwards as it probably explains a lot towards the treatment of press photographers by police over the last few years. If the man in charge of public order policing doesn’t know how the UK Press Card works it’s little surprise so few police respect it.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

The Commanders Speech.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Discussion with Commander Broadhurst.

Police grab photographers on Tamil protests
20 May 2009
Police detain press photographer Justin Tallis at a Pro-Tamil protest on Westminster bridge.

Police detain press photographer Justin Tallis at a Pro-Tamil protest on Westminster bridge.

For the second time in a week Police grabbed a press photographer from the ongoing Tamil protests outside Parliament.

Last Monday Chief EPA Photographer Andy Rain was grabbed by two senior officers as police were attempting to remove the protesters from the road and escorted him away from the protest.

Chief EPA Photographer, Andy Rain, is pulled from the crowd of protesters by a police inspector and sergeant and was escorted away from the protest.

Chief EPA Photographer, Andy Rain, is pulled from the crowd of protesters by a police inspector and sergeant and was escorted away from the protest.

On Monday they went one step further by forcibly detaining agency photographer Justin Tallis and questioning him in the back of a police van.

2009-05-18_k8k0188

Police question and detain press photographer Justin Tallis in a police van.

Officers did not say he was under arrest or under what power he was being detained. After pressure from fellow journalists and NUJ General Secretary Jeremy Dear speaking to senior officers on the ground via mobile phone he was released.

After being released Tallis received medical attention from London Ambulance Service paramedics. Tallis is considering legal action against officers with NUJ support.

NUJ Press Release
Video: Police Forcibly Detain Press Photographer